i wrote this when the aruna shanbaug case was on and forgot all about it. raju's father - mentioned in the post - died today. remembered this, so posting finally.
Death with Dignity
‘On Tuesday I'll finally end my battle with cancer thanks to Oregon's Death with dignity act. As part of my preparations I've ended my pain medication and am trying to regain what little dignity and clarity I can. Who I was doesn't matter. I'm in pain, I'm tired and I'm finally being granted a small shred of respect. Feel free to AMA if you're so inclined.’
Thus read a recent message posted by user ‘lucidending’ on Reddit, a popular social networking site. While his identity and authenticity cannot be ascertained, his posts received widespread attention with support and prayers pouring in from people across the world.
In India, the mercy killing plea of 60-year-old nurse Aruna Shanbaug, who has been living in a vegetative state for 37 years, has been rejected. Instead, what is supposedly a legally acceptable option of ‘passive euthanasia’ has been allowed, which to me seems more cruel than mercy killing. According to media reports, she was brutally raped, attacked and strangulated by a hospital employee. The oxygen supply to her brain was cut off and her cortex severely damaged. Passive euthanasia would now allow withdrawing artificial life support to Aruna leading to her death whenever that ‘naturally’ occurs.
Closer home, my gardener Raju (name and profession changed), whom I have now known for over 25 years, has been handling the dilapidating condition of his father caused by a severe kidney problem. The treatment runs into several lakhs and the old man is dying a slow death with no hope of recovery. When his condition worsens, Raju told me, even his mother asks him not to bother taking her husband to the hospital. ‘Lekin dil nahi manta. Pitaji hain,’ he said. Raju visits his home every couple of hours to turn his father on the bed to avoid bed sores, wakes up several times at night to take him to the toilet. His father continues to lead a meaningless existence financially and emotionally draining the family in the process, and would probably die leaving nothing – in every sense of the word - behind.
When my grandmother, who raised me for a few years when I was a young brat, died a year back after prolonged illness, many of us were relieved. It was pitiable watching her suffer but I could not blame those relatives who were impatiently waiting for her to breathe her last. I cannot imagine an existence of endless dependence on others, making myself miserable and loading guilt on others for rightfully loving me a little less with each passing sick day. My Aachi, however, was fortunate enough to have a selfless daughter who took excellent care of her till the end. Not many are as lucky.
I don’t understand why we don’t have a ‘Death with Dignity Act’ like the state of Oregon. What right does the government have to force upon anyone, especially in a country like India where millions live without a roof over their head, a degrading, humiliating existence when it cannot promise a life of dignity to those suffering? Why cannot it put adequate checks and balances with the help of its judicial and law enforcement agencies to ensure such Acts are not misused? Why give a million crushing deaths to the dying under the garb of humanitarian protection? If your own life does not belong to you at a stage when all that you are left with is that shred of existence, what does?
i am amazed at the number of creative vents the BP disaster has resulted in. it started with @BPGlobalPR, others followed such as the campaign to redesign the BP logo. i don't think any other crisis has seen the amount and level of creative and comic outpouring this one has. i am not sure if this will be the trend going forward. it also poses an interesting challenge to organisations. while inaccurate facts could be countered and allegations challenged, how does one counter sarcasm.. a spoof id or humourous post and not be seen silly? organisations need to take this into account as part of their crisis preparedness and management efforts.
Digital media have made creating and disseminating text, sound, and images cheap, easy and global. The bulk of publicly available media is now created by people who understand little of the professional standards and practices for media.
Instead, these amateurs produce endless streams of mediocrity, eroding cultural norms about quality and acceptability, and leading to increasingly alarmed predictions of incipient chaos and intellectual collapse.
But of course, that's what always happens. Every increase in freedom to create or consume media, from paperback books to YouTube, alarms people accustomed to the restrictions of the old system, convincing them that the new media will make young people stupid. This fear dates back to at least the invention of movable type.
As Gutenberg's press spread through Europe, the Bible was translated into local languages, enabling direct encounters with the text; this was accompanied by a flood of contemporary literature, most of it mediocre. Vulgar versions of the Bible and distracting secular writings fueled religious unrest and civic confusion, leading to claims that the printing press, if not controlled, would lead to chaos and the dismemberment of European intellectual life.
reading this article 'does the internet make you smarter?' by clay shirky, i could not help but wonder if the intellectual collapse he is referring to is also intellectual snobbery to some extent. the information overload would not exist if there were no takers for it..or would it? how do you define 'intelligent' content? what's 'silly' to one could well be 'very funny' or 'meaningful' to another. wouldn't evolving communities automatically manage the information overload challenge?
here's another great read on the subject:http://confusedofcalcutta.com/2010/06/06/thinking-about-democratised-curation/
the author quotes google ceo eric schmidt:
“…. the statistic that we have been using is between the dawn of civilisation and 2003, five exabytes of information were created. In the last two days, five exabytes of information have been created, and that rate is accelerating. And virtually all of that is what we call user-generated what-have-you. So this is a very, very big new phenomenon.”
mind-boggling, eh?
finally, a simple practical solution to get one started on managing information from louis gray.
yesterday, i was putting together a list of tech/telecom bloggers in india (caveat: i do not know the t of technology; the list was for a firm i consult with) when i turned to twitter for help.
i tweeted: can you please point me to a credible list of leading tech/telecom bloggers in india? @labnol can you help? thanks. nikhil was the first one to respond when he pointed me to this thread. labnol tweeted this: Please suggest your favorite tech and telecom bloggers in India - you may use the hash tag #BlogsILove cc: @surekhapillaiwhat follows is a compilation of responses i received. some of you might find this useful. please note this might not be the definitive list of the top tech bloggers in india, so please use this at your own discretion. sorry for not linking the urls and the tweets are in no particular order. Medianama, Emergic.org and sramanamitra.com (suggested by a respected tech blogger)@realmadrid_rock: @denharsh (http://shoutmeloud.com) @srikapardhi: #BlogsILove cc: @surekhapillai MyTelecomIdeas@DrJohnnySpin: #BlogsIiove @telecomtalk @surekhapillai @vaibhavkanwal: My favourite mobile technology author is @Djain1989 for mobilegyaan.com #BlogsILove cc: @surekhapillai @MobiGyaan: @labnol tech blog @labnol, @devils_workshop @amitbhawani --- telecom - @mobigyaan, @fonearena cc: @surekhapillai @srikapardhi: Telecom #BlogsIiove @telecomtalk @surekhapillai @nickbyte: @surekhapillai telecom #BlogsILove @TelecomTalk THE BEST IN INDIA @CricNewz: @surekhapillai Telecom #BlogsILove @telecomtalk @raxit: #BlogsILove Telecom blogs @TelecomTalk @surekhapillai @asifahmd: @surekhapillai Telecom blogs @TelecomTalk #BlogsILove @ialtaf: @surekhapillai Telecom blogs @TelecomTalk #BlogsILove @sgsan: @TelecomTalk #BlogsILove @surekhapillai @taruntanu: Tech - @Blogsdna @tothepc | Telecom blogs - @TelecomTalk #BlogsILove @surekhapillai @amit_banerjee: tech - @labnol @guidingtech @techiebuzzer #BlogsILove cc: @surekhapillai @NeerajKumar_: Shoutmeloud.com, millionclues.com, labnol.org, blogtechnika.com are few of the #BlogsILove @surekhapillai Just indian blogs?or others too? @_navin: @labnol #BlogsILove http://blog.dhananjaynene.com/ by @dnene cc: @surekhapillai @vadakkus: MediaNama.com @anandace: @surekhapillai try http://tech2.in.com/ @PaiRSquare: @labnol tech blogger would be u.. #BlogsILove labnol.org @surekhapillai @girishmallya: @surekhapillai ask @veer @ranjanv: @surekhapillai Try @labnol Blog Directory http://www.labnol.org/india-blogs/indian-bloggers.html @realmadrid_rock: @surekhapillai know one tech blogger @denharsh (http://shoutmeloud.com) @nixxin: @surekhapillai hey. @mrunmaiy put up a list @ http://bit.ly/aWBMXU, incl mobiles. not something I like,but then i put my no up frequently @dnyaneshmankar: favourite telecom blog: www.mobilegyaan.com #BlogsILove @JaggedArrowHead: #BlogsILove nampblog.com , teknots.com @Compixels: @labnol Self love for our blog @Compixels . 1 week old Tech blog waiting for that big day :) #BlogsILove @tsuvik: @labnol Tech Blogs - @labnol @techpp @techbangalore and Telecom - @techknots @zomgitscj @fonearena #BlogsILove @binoyxj: @labnol Sorry, can i suggest your blog also? :D #BlogsILove @unitechy: tech - @labnol @techpp @techiebuzzer @blogsdna and Telecom - @fonearena @techknots @cellpassion #BlogsILove @binoyxj: Tech - @Blogsdna @tothepc @amitbhawani | Telecom blogs - @TelecomTalk @FoneArena #BlogsILove @labnol @Compixels: Tech - @Blogsdna @tothepc @amitbhawani | Telecom blogs - @TelecomTalk @FoneArena #BlogsILove @labnol @Niyukti: Among Tech Blogger @labnol wins hands down #BlogsILovefeel free to add to the list in the comments section. thank you everybody for the response. thank you, amit.this is proof that an empty mind is the devil's workshop. thanks @mohak and @vulturo for indulging me. all for a little fun!
i had a 'twitter chat' earlier today with arnab ray aka @greatbong. arnab is among the funniest indians on twitter and the author of ‘may I hebb your attention pliss’ to be launched in delhi soon. there is a contest running as part of the book promotion which is already seeing some hilarious entries like this one.
while there has been a steady stream of buzz around sidin’s ‘dork’, arnab’s ‘MIHYAP’ has not quite taken off - not on twitter atleast. it made me wonder whether it had anything to do with how both use twitter. im not sure about others but i personally feel greatbong is funnier than sidin while sidin has been a better marketer on twitter. thanks to his popularity, sidin also has an army of marketers and cheerleaders supporting dork whereas MIHYAP has not had as many takers. it intrigued me as a communications professional. i tweeted this observation not thinking much about it. i expected to be fully ignored by both sidin and greatbong.
here’s the ‘chat ‘transcript:
surekhapillai how @sidin & @greatbong are using twitter for their books will make a great case study . support for @sidin has been great, not sure about G
greatbong @surekhapillai No not as much. Help anyone !
surekhapillai i was right. +1 for @greatbong for this reply though. im buying hebb. RT @greatbong @surekhapillai No not as much. Help anyone !
surekhapillai @greatbong your interaction on twitter somehow gives the impression youd rather be left alone. youre not really a people person are you?
greatbong @surekhapillai And why do you think my interaction on Twitter gives you the impression I would like to be left alone? Curious pliss.
surekhapillai @greatbong mm..you are more of a broadcaster here, you follow none. i once called you the buckingham palace when i wrote a post on twitter.
surekhapillai @greatbong your replies till recently seemed more of a courtesy than real engagement. you could be perceived as elitist. ok analysis done.
surekhapillai @greatbong oh last point. the irony in all of this is youre definitely funnier than anyone else. you could get a lot more out of this medium
greatbong @surekhapillai Assmption 1: Following none implies arrogance (Buckingham Palace) A 2: You have read all my tweets to everyone. To continue..
greatbong @surekhapillai Pity you didnt attend my online question and answer session for a first hand look at my level of interactivity.
surekhapillai @greatbong not saying youre not interactive. im sure youre not this popular by being an island. shared my impressions on how you use twitter
greatbong @surekhapillai Dont think I am funnier @Sidin has a very good product. Hence great buzz. Now I wud like to believe my product is good too.
greatbong @surekhapillai And so surprised at lack of buzz.
surekhapillai @greatbong that lack of buzz vis-a-vis @sidin could also be because he carries more people with him here.
surekhapillai @greatbong honestly speaking im very surprised youre having this discussion with me here. i expected both of you to ignore me.
greatbong @surekhapillai Again what does carries mean? Not too sure.
surekhapillai @greatbong he builds them up, he RTs comments, he takes interest in what they say by following them , he seems to genuinely enjoy himself.
surekhapillai @greatbong that is real two-way communication imo
greatbong @surekhapillai "expected both of" me? Ailaaaa ! Me split personality !
greatbong @surekhapillai Again dont think u hv rd all the interactions with ppl on Tw Either that or I dont know what "interactivity" is in this world
surekhapillai @greatbong ha! definitely seems like im talking to your twin here.
surekhapillai @greatbong not all. but most yes. ive been taking active interest in you (let me hasten to add, for professional reasons!). having said ½
surekhapillai @greatbong 2/2 that i could be wrong here. your personal brand could be different from his and this air of exclusivity might actually help.
greatbong @surekhapillai Comes back to following . BTW if I am not wrong @sidin does not follow me. I still would promote his book coz he is awesome
surekhapillai @greatbong thank you for this discussion. delighted my 'may-i-hebb-your-attention-please' tweet worked.
greatbong @surekhapillai Actually my blog's main message has been non-exclusiveness. I find beauty in that which elites turn their noses up at.
greatbong @surekhapillai Yes thank you too for the discussion. Both of us mean that.
surekhapillai @greatbong thats interesting. i should talk to your fans then perhaps to know what draws them to you and how they see you as a person.
surekhapillai @greatbong lol. i meant you and sidin. grrr. thanks again.
greatbong @surekhapillai Please do.
greatbong @surekhapillai And thanks again 2. (Yes "2")
this conversation left me with these thoughts – not all are necessarily in the arnab context:
- objectivity is the toughest challenge on twitter. our own personal experiences and loosely formed impressions lead to biases in how we perceive a person. criticism, of course, comes easy.
- pretence: is it ok to be someone youre inherently not just to push a product/service. we tend to get friendly when it serves our purpose. is it fair for smart marketing and packaging to score over genuine honesty alebit with some rough edges?
as for arnab, i know im buying his book. if humour is your thing and youre still not sure, this should clinch the deal for you. the last part of the chat when sidin walked in:
sidin @surekhapillai @greatbong Eh? What is this debate? GB let us chest butt and put this to rest.
greatbong @sidin Putting chest to butt isnt a proper idea.
sidin May I hebb your excyuuj pliss. RT @greatbong: @sidin Putting chest to butt isnt a proper idea.
-the end-
image from http://greatbong.net/
recently pritish nandy and vir sanghvi jointly agreed to take the RTI route to challenge the government's controversial decision to award padma bhushan to sant singh chatwal. their joint declaration met with overwhelming support from twitterers including me. in fact i even joked with a friend later that day that sanghvi and nandy would probably be on the phone telling each other "saala ab to karna hi padega".
much to their credit both of them have been keeping twitterati regularly updated on the developments on this front. today came another unexpected announcement from vir sanghvi. that got me thinking and the result is a mail sent to both on the honestawards id. i do not want to grade issues here, so this is not a are-lives-lost-not-more-important-than-awards-won rant, nor am i proposing both become 'sants'. it's a mere suggestion, that's all. here's the mail:Dear Mr Sanghvi, Mr Nandy, This is to confirm my support for your 'Honest Awards' initiative. My twitter id is @surekhapillai and I am a communications/PR professional. Please let me know if there is anything I can do to help. I sincerely hope you can continue this partnership to usher in more meaningful changes that directly impact people like us. Working towards bringing in greater transparency in governance in general and not just awards, for instance. The way in which government shares information could be another area - one look at their information dissemination tools like websites is enough to see the shocking state of affairs. I believe the clout and influence you wield, combined with the support you are bound to get on Twitter and outside, could be put to greater use.Sincerely,